Plus/minus: Aston Villa, Cardiff City, Manchester United, Southampton & Tottenham Hotspur; 16th December 2013

Aston Villa

C

Wilfried Zaha: Destination West Bromwich

Wilfried Zaha, Manchester United's most exciting (and most underutilised) acquisition of 2013, seems likely to be loaned out to another Premier League club this winter. The clubs associated include Everton (surprise, surprise), Newcastle United and, predictably, former club Crystal Palace.

United fans were initially excited by Zaha’s unharnessed horsepower, but his inability to break into David Moyes’ convulsant first team sees Red Devil fans enticed by what he might be, rather than what he will contribute to 2013-14. That probably means seeing him temporarily don blue or black and white.

A good argument is made by NBC’s Pro Soccer Talk that Everton might be an agreeable loan destination: the Toffees might be able to take points from other teams competing for the top four while getting the young England international the competition he needs to develop. A bonus comes in the form of manager Roberto Martinez, who dating back to his days at Swansea has nonpareil form at turning loan players into monsters.

What this theory fails to account for is that Everton, driven by a compelling foursome of loanees (Gareth Barry, Gerard Delofeu, Romelu Lukaku and possibly Zaha), might themselves muster enough points to keep United from Champions League qualification. Although it seems less likely, the same might be said of Newcastle United.

While Everton, Newcastle and Palace seem the most likely Zaha destinations, an under-the-radar option might exist. West Bromwich Albion boast a coach-turned-manager in Steve Clarke who managed the club to an upper half EPL finish last year and who has with Roy Hodgson turned a former yo-yo team into a solid Premiership club – albeit one that still appears to lack goals. Clarke also used temp man Romelu Lukaku in a devastating manner last year, has developed young winger Saido Berahino into a wonderful international prospect.

The Baggies sit fifteenth in the table and seem to have based much of their recruitment on maximizing returns from good, but not great players. The addition of Lukaku – who lopes around the field with the speed and manner of a big cat hunting – last term provided a physical weapon capable of freezing opposing defenses and creating space for midfielders like James Morrison. Were West Brom able to rotate Scott Sinclair, Berahino and Zaha, their forward corps would be perhaps more fascinating viewing than even the Man U Moyespocalypse.

Whether the Baggies have the available squad space and finances to make such a deal work remains questionable, but the club is certainly an option worth considering. It might make West Brom better, it would almost certainly make Wilfried Zaha better and would give fans of each side even more to tune in to.

Plus/minus: Aston Villa, Cardiff City, Manchester United, Southampton, Tottenham, 6th December 2013

Aston Villa

Player	Games	Minutes	GS	GA	Plus/minus	Scored/90	Conc/90	Team GD
Guzan	14	1260	16	16	0	1.143	1.143	0
Baker	8	643	10	11	-1	1.400	1.540	0
Vlaar	14	1215	14	14	0	1.037	1.037	0
Luna	11	945	12	12	0	1.143	1.143	0
Lowton	7	560	9	8	1	1.446	1.286	0
El Ahmadi	13	1017	13	13	0	1.150	1.150	0
Westwood	12	1073	11	14	-3	0.923	1.174	0
Delph	12	1023	14	14	0	1.232	1.232	0
Weimann	13	946	11	12	-1	1.047	1.142	0
Agbonlahor	11	893	11	12	-1	1.109	1.209	0
Benteke	12	929	10	12	-2	0.969	1.163	0
Clark	12	945	15	10	5	1.429	0.952	0
Bacuna	12	992	11	11	0	0.998	0.998	0
Okore	3	167	1	3	-2	0.539	1.617	0
Tonev	10	374	3	3	0	0.722	0.722	0
Helenius	3	49	0	1	-1	0.000	1.837	0
Kozak	10	574	9	7	2	1.411	1.098	0
Sylla	6	358	5	4	1	1.257	1.006	0
Bowery	3	27	0	0	0	0.000	0.000	0
Albrighton	1	19	0	0	0	0.000	0.000	0

Spurs/United a preview of what might eventually be

Let’s talk about neurology (again). Specifically, let’s talk about the way the human nervous system deals with learning a new strategy – either a movement strategy or a new way of applying what knowledge you already have.

Technically speaking, learning is a relatively permanent change, a product of a change in the architecture of the body’s nervous systems. Performance is another matter altogether; it is a temporary change in behaviour observed during supervised practice. It depends on many factors including the environment and the level of ambient stress.

Now, let’s talk about football – and more accurately, about this weekend’s past match between Tottenham Hotspur and Manchester United. Both teams are acclimating to new personnel, and thereby learning new tactics, methods and movements.

David Moyes’ arrival means the entire club is adapting to a new way of doing things, while the Whites have replaced a once-in-a-generation player with a wide array of disparate talents like Erik Lamela, Andros Townsend, Paulinho and Roberto Soldado. Each new player is now – and still – adapting to Andre Villas-Boas and the way he thinks about football and demands it played.

To expect instant change, or a team to understand implicitly a new motor learning strategy within months is unrealistic – for someone to retrain a learned behaviour, it takes anywhere as much as 400 repetitions. Add to that the communication barrier – message, language or mode – and suddenly it becomes reasonable to expect any particular situational play to take months to consolidate.

Occasions of exquisite performance, such as Manchester United’s 5-0 triumph over Bayer Leverkusen in the Champions League last week, can occur despite a lack of learning. Sometimes, circumstances transpire to create an atmosphere in which performance can occur despite a lack of learning. The learning will occur as each player’s reps increase, with the most benefit coming from time spent on the field in matches, rather than the training ground.

Plus/minus, Tottenham Hotspur, 2nd December 2013

Plus/minus, Southampton, 2nd December 2013

Plus/minus, Manchester United, 2nd December 2013

Plus/minus, Cardiff City, 2nd December 2013

Plus/minus, Aston Villa, 2nd December 2013